Best Spare Tire Winches of 2020 – Ultimate Buyer’s Guide

Are you looking for the best spare tire winches? If so, then you are not alone. It is important that you find a winch that will come in handy for not only yourself but also for those who may need a tire replacement in emergency situations. You’ll need a winch that will safely tow vehicles while they are on a spare tire or if they are dealing with a flat and are in need of urgent repairs.

While so many spare tire winches are available on the market, we’ve handpicked five of the best for our review. We consider these to be the most popular on the market and suggest that you choose one from the list. 


Before we get to the list itself, we’ll talk about what a spare tire winch is and how you can choose one for your own personal use.


Comparison Chart of the Best Spare Tire Winches

PRODUCT DETAILS
gm2-table__image

Lippert 159056-Spare Tire Winch

  • Made from high-quality materials
  • Best overall and best RV spare tire winch
  • Designed for the use of cars, RVs, and trucks
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Dorman 924 502 Spare Tire Hoist

  • Designed as a factory replacement
  • Runner-up for best spare tire winch
  • Manufactured from high-quality materials
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Dorman 924-510 Replacement Spare Hoist

  • Designed for trucks
  • Made from a rust-resistant material
  • Best spare tire winch for the money
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Dodge Spare Winch Hoist Factory

  • Easy storage space
  • Made from high-quality materials
  • Best Dodge Ram 1500 spare tire winch
View Latest Price
gm2-table__image

Spare Tire Hoist

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Best spare tire winch for Ford F150s
  • Designed as an OEM replacement tire hoist
View Latest Price

What is a Spare Tire Winch?

Spare tire winches are designed for you to use while you are in the process of replacing a tire that is damaged or flattened due to lack of air. This is designed to safely tow or even lift a part of the vehicle off the road so, the tire or vehicle itself does not incur any damage if it is en route to a garage. 

How to Choose a Spare Tire Winch

The goal here is to help you find a spare tire winch that is best for you. But finding one for the purpose of your own use will take some time and knowing how to distinguish a great tire winch from one that isn’t so great. Here are the following things to look for:

Price

If you are on a budget, then you may want to consider investing in the best quality and performance that you can afford. This way, you are investing money into something valuable rather than throwing money away on something that is considered cheap and flimsy. The price tag should not be the “be all, end all” factor when choosing a winch.

Weight Limit

The weight limit of a winch is important because of the number of vehicles you might be hauling (assuming you are doing this working as a mechanic). At the same time, you’ll want something that will be tough enough to do a good amount of pulling for short or long distances. A heavier weight limit can be a good indicator that the cable or the entire winch system itself is sturdy enough to handle the intended tasks.

Cable Length

The length of a cable will certainly be a factor if you are looking for a winch for your own use. The longer it is, the better the chance you will be using it for the purpose of not just towing but also pulling vehicles out of ditches as well. A spare tire winch might just have enough to double up as a rescue tool for those who have run off the road in certain road conditions (i.e.--winter weather). 

Quick Take - Best Spare Tire Winches

Skip the review - here are the best spare tire winches:

  1. Lippert 159056-Spare Tire Winch
  2. Dorman 924 502 Spare Tire Hoist
  3. Dorman 924-510 Replacement Spare Hoist

Review of the Best Spare Tire Winches

The following is a list of the five best spare tire winches that are currently popular on the market. As you go through each one, it’s important to note the features and characteristics so you can find one that might be the better choice for you. Sometimes, it’s good to have a description of an ideal “spare tire winch”. Find the one that is close enough and you just might find a winner. Here is the first spare tire winch on our list -- the “best overall” choice:

Best Overall and Best RV Spare Tire Winch:
Lippert 159056-Spare Tire Winch

Lippert 159056 RV Spare Tire Winch

PROS

  • Easy to mount
  • Cable is strong and durable
  • Can hold up tires that weigh around 100 pounds
  • Can handle the long-distance trips (i.e.--Cross-country travel)
  • Excellent tire winch that holds up really well, especially with RVs

CONS

  • Cranking may be tough at times
  • Crank and other needed accessories are sold separately
  • Some have complained that there is no weight limit rating 

What Recent Buyers Report

A lot of new buyers were satisfied with the winch for a few good reasons. One, they utilized it for the purpose of carrying spare tires for their vehicles. They were happy with the winch’s ability to handle so many tires of different sizes and weights (up to 100 pounds). One user said that he had to use it to carry a replacement tire from a garage to a roadside emergency that was located some 20 miles away. He said the winch held up pretty good even when traveling distances that are not so short. He also added that the winch was sturdy and showed no signs of breaking or wearing down. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

This winch is one of those simple to use spare tire winches that will work to your advantage, if you have this stored away in the trunk of your car or bed of your truck. Either way, it’s at the right size where you can take it just about anywhere and use it in case you need to deliver a spare tire to someone who may need a replacement. This also has the ability to handle tires that are large and heavy in size. So, it can handle tires that go to RVs and even some small tractor-trailer trucks (assuming they will fit). So, if you are looking for a nice sized spare tire winch that will be excellent in emergency situations and can handle so many new tires, this might be the one you end up going with. 

Who Will Use This Most

This will be a great spare tire winch for those who are auto mechanics that do this on a regular basis or a regular motor vehicle operator that will have it handy just in case they or anyone else are in trouble to a point where a tire will need to be replaced. It’s sturdy, durable, and all-around reliable. So, if you want a spare tire winch that will fit in your trunk or truck bed, this is possibly what you might end up going with.

Bottom Line

If you want a spare tire winch that will be easy to use and simple to handle for most spares, the Lippert RV Spare Tire Winch might be the go-to option for you. Don’t be surprised if this winds up being super reliable and able to handle the towing duties for quite a while. It’s pretty strong and won’t fall apart easily thanks to the high-quality materials being used for the towing cable. 

Dorman 924-502 Spare Tire Hoist

PROS

  • Installs in as little as five minutes
  • Can handle oversized tires with ease
  • Cable is coated for corrosion resistance
  • Works on most vehicles like trucks and RVs
  • No pesky safety catch to interfere with the operation

CONS

  • None

What Recent Buyers Report

Most of the new buyers were satisfied with this spare tire winch, especially when they found out it was able to handle oversized and even a good number of heavy weight tires. Most of the new users were either RV or truck owners looking for the perfect winch that would not only tow their tires but also their vehicles as well in the event of an emergency situation. The rope was super sturdy and had the ability to handle heavy weights like a pro.

Why it Stands Out to Us

This might be a threat to take the “best overall” spot in the not so distant future. One of the major reasons is the winch’s ability to handle tires that are usually oversized and perhaps a little too much to handle for some competition winches. So, it will be ideal for trucks and even RVs that need tire replacement. Flat tire? No problem. Just find your replacement tire, install it on this winch, and it can go the distance and handle the weight or size of the tire itself. If you want something that can be a winch for the big boys, this might be what you’ll need.

Who Will Use This Most


This will certainly be the spare tire winch for truck and RV operators everywhere. If it can handle the tires that some other winches won’t, then it’s obvious that it will be an advantage coming into the competition against some other winches. This winch, in particular, is no joke. If it can handle the heavy-duty tires, you best believe it will stand out as the best possible choice for many a truck driver or RV owner.

Bottom Line

Dorman Spare Tire Hoist is definitely going to be a favorite among those who want a winch that can handle the big tires. You’d be hard-pressed to find any kind of winch that can handle the duties of carrying heavy or large tires from distances near or far. It’s got the stability, durability, and it’s simply one of the best. If you need a winch that just might take over the top spot over the next year or so, this might be one to get.

Dorman 924-510 Replacement Spare Tire Hoist for Select Chevrolet/GMC Trucks

PROS

  • Easy to install
  • Fits in most truck beds
  • Affordable for most budgets
  • Excellent for even older model trucks
  • Can handle long distances (i.e.--cross-country road trips)

CONS

  • May need to be greased before use
  • Cable may be a bit difficult to deploy at first
  • Some have complained about the absence of a safety catch

What Recent Buyers Report

Most of the new buyers were happy with the winch’s ability to go the distance. Whether it was 10 miles or 1000 miles, they were not disappointed with how well the winch could handle spare tires. One user said that he thought the cable was going to give in after he was making a 200-mile trip to deliver a tire to a friend of his. But so far, he was not disappointed and said that it still has plenty of gas left in the tank for repeated use.

Why it Stands Out to Us

For the price it’s going for, it can handle many of the heavy-duty towing and lifting duties. It’s tough, easy to install, and can handle trucks and spare tires like nothing else. So in short, it’s a rugged-looking unit that backs it up by handling the heavy lifting. And since it’s pretty affordable, you’re probably going to make off like a bandit should you choose this as your winch of choice. If you have a truck, this winch will do you proud.

Who Will Use This Most

This will be an excellent spare tire winch that will be great for newbie users. Especially those who own trucks or even RVs. It’s easy to install, easy to store away, and can get the job done when it comes to trucks or heavy spare tires that will go the distance. If you want a winch that can be tough and be considered the ultimate road warrior, this is it.

Bottom Line

The Dorman Replacement Spare Tire Hoist is the best you can get at a price you can afford. And it can rack up some mileage without even a single hint of giving in or breaking apart. It’s probably the best option you can find for your truck if you are on a budget or if you have money to play with. You’d be shocked what a “budget” spare tire winch can do compared to some higher-end models.

Best Dodge Ram 1500 Spare Tire Winch:
Dodge Spare Winch Hoist Factory

DODGE RAM 1500 2500 3500 SPARE TIRE WINCH HOIST LIFT MOPAR FACTORY OEM NEW

PROS

  • Fits in most truck beds
  • Handles oversized tires
  • Supports most Dodge Ram 1500 trucks
  • Lasts longer when sprayed with Bedliner
  • Easy to install, takes about 10 minutes in total

CONS

  • Some have said that it might be a bit too pricey
  • Some holes may need to be drilled in order to align it properly

What Recent Buyers Report

A lot of new buyers were happy with the winch’s ability to handle Dodge Ram trucks and their tires. They said that the winch was pretty tough and could handle the hoisting of tires (especially the wide and heavy tires). One user said that he was looking for a winch that was able to last a long time and be able to handle his Dodge truck (since he’s been driving nothing but Dodge trucks for the past decade). He said he had no complaints with the tires holding up pretty good, even when he had to travel 100 miles at one point to carry a replacement tire back to his garage.

Why it Stands Out to Us

This winch is perhaps one of the best you can find that will be able to handle Dodge trucks. And best of all, it has a 12-month warranty that will be honored at any Dodge dealership in the country. So, if you are close to home or on the other end of the country and your winch fails you, you’ll have a Dodge dealer that will give you a hand in making sure that it is replaced so long as it’s in warranty. The winch itself does a good job handling Dodge Ram compatible tires and can hold them for as long as possible no matter how far you are going. The cable is easy to deploy and you can crank and lift tires with ease no matter what the weight is. If you want something that is strong and simple to use along with your Dodge Ram 1500, this just might be the go-to option for you.

Who Will Use This Most

This winch is exclusively made for Dodge Ram 1500 users. So, if you have that kind of truck, you will have no problem putting this to good use. Just install it, spray on some Bedliner and you just might have a tire winch that will get the job done for as long as you use it. There is no question that you’ll be able to use this to your advantage when it comes time to tow or even hoist spare tires. It can handle the large and heavy tires like nothing else. And most of the Dodge Ram trucks are known for being tough as nails, so this winch is equally tough. If you agree, get this winch and give it a try.

Bottom Line

The Dodge Ram 1500 Spare Tire Winch is the go-to choice for your Dodge Ram truck if you want something that is tough, easy to use, and able to handle most tires from short and long distances. Fit this on your truck bed and you’ll have a winch that is good to go if and when you need it. You’ll use it constantly or on occasions, but it can remain sturdy and reliable for many years to come.

Best Ford F150 Spare Tire Winch:
Spare Tire Hoist

Spare Tire Hoist - Fits 1997-2003 Ford F-150, F150 Heritage, 1997, 1998, 1999 F-250, 97 F-250HD and 2002 Lincoln Blackwood - Replaces 924526, 1L3Z1A131AA, 2L3Z1A131AA - Reserve Tyre Holder Assembly

PROS

  • Super sturdy construction
  • Excellent fit for most users
  • Can hoist and perform long-term
  • Easy to install, takes a few minutes
  • Handles most large and heavy tires

CONS

  • None

What Recent Buyers Report

As expected, a lot of new buyers were happy with this spare tire winch. A lot of new users were of course owners of Ford F150 trucks. And they were not disappointed when they were able to fit this on their truck beds. One user said that he was able to attach it to his truck in a few minutes’ time. So far, he had no complaints and he was able to hoist many tires on a regular basis for his auto shop business. The cable itself was pretty strong and could handle most of the heavy weight tires, he also added.

Why it Stands Out to Us

The Ford F150 is considered to be one of the toughest trucks on the market. So it makes sense to get a winch that is equally tough. This spare tire winch is perhaps one of the best fitting for such a truck, especially when you have a good amount of space to attach it. Best of all, it’s compatible with so many F150 models both new and old. So don’t guess whether your truck is compatible with this winch. If it’s a 1995 or 2005, this winch will still get the job done. 

Who Will Use This Most

This will obviously be put to good use by many F150 users. Whether you have owned it for years or just bought it, this winch will certainly go above and beyond the call of duty and fulfill your tire hoisting and towing needs. If you are looking for a winch that is built Ford tough, this just might be right up your alley. 

Bottom Line

The Spare Tire Hoist from AA Ignition is one of the best hoists for spare tires that you can find for a Ford F150 truck. It’s tough, durable, and does exactly what a spare tire winch should do. Whether you are going down the road or traveling a long distance, this winch can handle tires and hold them in place without giving in or losing strength over time. 

Aspects to Consider Before Buying

Aside from the features and characteristics, it’s important to consider some additional aspects that will factor into your final purchasing decision. You will need to consider these with more weight compared to some other deciding factors like price, quality, and whatever else. Here is what you should consider:

What Sort of Tires Will It Handle?

If you are using it for personal use, it’s important to determine which winch you want to use and which tires it is able to carry. If you are looking for a winch that will handle larger tires, then you’ll need to find a winch that has a higher weight capacity. This way, you can operate a winch without risking any damage or breaking it due to heavy weight.

Will It Fit Your Vehicle?

Many winches are available in different sizes and are compatible with some specific trucks. It is important to determine whether or not your potential winch of choice is will be a universal model or something that will be specifically made and fit for trucks of a specific brand (Ex: Dodge or Ford).

Should It Handle Long Road Trips?

You want to look for a spare tire winch that will be perfect for the long haul. You could be just about anywhere and a service station can be a bit farther away. But if you can handle the drive to and from, a great spare tire winch can even handle heavy tires no matter how far you travel. If it can handle cross country road trips, it’s certainly the kind of model you’ll want. 

Cautious Considerations to Keep in Mind

It’s important to know about these additional considerations so you are well aware of them and also able to use a spare tire winch properly. Transporting spare tires safely and securely is a priority that should be met each time you use a spare tire winch. Here are some things you need to cautiously consider:

Some Winches Won’t Handle Large Tires

Some winches can handle only regular cart or truck tires, but may not be able to handle the tires of much larger vehicles. Carrying a tire that is clearly above capacity in weight or size can cause the winch to break and possibly cause a good amount of damage to your vehicle (or worse). Be sure to know the weight limit and abide by it when the winch is in good use. 

Winches May Only Fit On Certain Trucks

Keep in mind that these winches are mostly built to be fit on truck beds, not vehicles like cars. At the same time, you need to consider the size and weight of your winch so you can install it easily and use it without doing further structural damage to the vehicle. Remember, smaller winches can work with smaller model trucks while large winches can work just fine with large or diesel-powered trucks.

Conclusion

The best spare tire winch is out there. And it will take a bit of time before you finally choose one for your own use. Study the list above and find one that is durable and reliable enough for all your heavy lifting needs. Pay close attention to some of the information like weight capacity or rope length so you have a good idea of how you can use it properly and safely.